Monthly Rental vs. Short-Term Rental in Knoxville & Surrounding Areas: What’s Better for Your Income?

If you're exploring real estate in the Knoxville area, investing or expanding into nearby markets - Jefferson City, Jefferson County, Morristown, New Market, Sevierville, Dandridge, or Maryville—one of the first questions you’ll face is: Should you focus on monthly rental income or short-term rental income?

Both strategies can be profitable in these Tennessee markets, but they serve different purposes. The right choice depends on your financial goals, property location, and management preferences. This guide compares monthly vs. short-term rentals so you can determine the best strategy for your investment across these areas.

Monthly Rentals in Knoxville & Surrounding Markets: Stability and Predictability

A monthly (or long-term) rental involves leasing your property for a set period, such as several months, six months, or a year. Many investors favor this route because:

• Consistent monthly rental income — your cash flow is more predictable across Knoxville, Jefferson City, Morristown, etc.
• Lower turnover — long-term tenants reduce vacancy and wear-and-tear.
• Less intensive management — you won’t need constant cleaning, key exchanges, or guest communication.
• Reliable tenant base — families, professionals, and students prefer stability.

This strategy is often ideal for investors who want reliable returns without active oversight.

Short-Term Rentals in Knoxville & Neighboring Cities: Flexibility and Upside

A short-term rental (STR), via platforms like Airbnb or VRBO, can often generate higher returns than long-term leasing, particularly in areas with high visitor traffic (proximity to UT Knoxville, Sevierville tourist areas, or cabins around Jefferson County). Advantages include:

• Higher income potential — in demand neighborhoods like downtown Knoxville, Sevierville (gateway to the Smokies), or Maryville, STRs can outperform long-term leases.
• Flexibility — rent per night or block dates for personal use.
• Appeal to visitors — tourists, UT parents, festival guests, and business travelers prefer short stays.
• Dynamic pricing — rates can adjust during UT football weekends, holiday seasons in Sevierville, or special events in Jefferson City.
• Scalable — with smart property management, you can manage multiple STRs across Knoxville, Morristown, or Dandridge.

However, this strategy demands more involvement or the hiring of local property management services.

Local Market Factors & Comparisons

When weighing monthly vs short-term rentals across the greater Knoxville area, consider:

Location & Demand

Properties in downtown Knoxville, near UT, in Sevierville (tourist corridor), or Maryville near amenities are prime for STRs. Suburban or rural areas (e.g., parts of Jefferson County, Dandridge) may perform more reliably with long-term tenants.

Local Regulations & Taxes

Each county and city may have different zoning laws, permit requirements, or lodging taxes. Knoxville, for instance, requires a permit for STRs (so always verify local guidelines). Be sure to review Knoxville rental laws, as well as the rules in Jefferson City, Sevierville, etc.

Management Effort

STRs require frequent cleaning, guest screening, listing updates, and prompt communication. If you don’t want that, a long-term model is more hands-off.

Risk & Vacancy

STR revenues can fluctuate due to seasonal lows, off-peak months, or sudden travel downturns, which can impact income. Long-term leases buffer these risks.

Diversification Strategy

Many investors adopt a hybrid approach: use long-term rentals in stable neighborhoods (Jefferson County, Maryville) and STRs in high-demand zones (downtown Knoxville, Sevierville). This spreads risk and optimizes returns.

Which Strategy Fits Best?

There’s no one-size-fits-all. But here’s a guideline based on your goals:

If you prioritize steady returns and minimal management, monthly leases are safer. If you're comfortable handling or outsourcing additional work and seeking higher returns, short-term rentals could be a more lucrative option.

Many successful investors use a mix across their portfolio, letting each property play to its strengths in its respective local area.

Connect with Local Experts Across East Tennessee

At Shawn Wilmoth Real Estate, I help investors select the best rental strategy across Knoxville, Jefferson City, Jefferson County, Morristown, New Market, Sevierville, Dandridge, and Maryville. Whether you need guidance comparing monthly rental vs short-term rentals, navigating local regulations in Sevierville or Jefferson County, or optimizing a multi-city real estate investing plan, I’ve got you covered. Contact me today!

Follow My Social Media Channels 

Interested in more content? Follow my social channels!

Instagram: @shawnroywilmoth

Facebook: Shawn Wilmoth Realtor 

LinkedIn: Shawn Wilmoth, CCIM REALTOR

TikTok: ShawnWilmothRealtor

Contact Me 

Phone: (865) 205-9353

Email: shawn@shawnwilmoth.com

Office: (865) 444-2400

Office Location: 308 N Peters Rd. STE 225 Knoxville, TN 37922 

Read More from my Real Estate Blog